Coach Denis Kanygin Blog

Kettlebells, Posture and All That Other Stuff That's Good For You

Review of Steve Cotter’s Encyclopedia of Kettlebell Lifting

Posted on | May 19, 2008 | 2 Comments

Got my hands on Steve Cotter’s “Encyclopedia of Kettlebell Lifting”.

Five DVD set and 7 hours of Kettlebells, the guy is sure a thorough fellow. I know of Steve’s reputation, his knowledge of the “Hard Style” RKC and involvement with AKC(Valery Fedorenko is a special guest on this set of DVDs) and was curious to see what Steve had to say about kettlebell training.

Overview:
Quality information, easy to digest. Presentation is simple, clear and easily understood. Although these series cannot replace a hands on instruction, it is a good second choice. It is a great series to learn the exercises and how to do them properly.

The series also include kettlebell workouts, from beginner to advanced. You can also find specialty programs targeting:

  • anaerobic conditioning
  • speed and strength
  • max speed, core strength
  • couple of programs for football Lineman
  • strength and endurance
  • strength and flexibility

Nice programs and nicely done yet they stand like an island in the ocean. There is no information about proper cycling, rest and recovery. If you want kettlebell program design and to learn how to USE the exercises(frequency, intensity, volume) look somewhere else.

Good for Beginners? Yes. Plenty of information. Easy to understand and follow.
Good for Intermediate Lifters? Yes. Plenty of variations.
Good for Expert Lifters? No. There are heavy and exotic lifts in these series by they are done in a YouTube style. Cotter performs the lifts without giving any insight into it. Entertaining? Sure. Useful? No.

Pluses:
Good presentation. Steve is a good communicator and is able to explain and show how it should be done. A great series for anyone looking into learning more about kettlebell training.

A perfect series for a complete beginner or intermediate level kettlebell lifter.

Minuses:
Does not have a chapter about how to pick the right kettlebell or when to progress to the next one.

No ranking system for the exercises. A system of prerequisites would have made this series a lot more user friendly and less confusing to a beginner.

Coach Fedorenko demonstrates competition style lifts but does not talk! I want to hear Fedorenko’s view, stories and experiences. If you invite someone of Valery’s caliber to the set, let them share what they know!

Watching Valery perform is inspiring yet not very useful, as he developed his own style. Beginners will try to mimic what he is doing and develop incorrect form. Not useful.

May not be the most important thing but the set is ugly! A DVD done on a beach or in a more pleasant setting would have been much more appealing to the eye.

Scroll down for a detailed review of the 7 hour series.

Volume 1: Introduction is thorough and perfect for beginners. In it Steve talks about basics:

  • Benefits of Kettlebell Training
  • Rules and Safety
  • Breathing and Mechanics
  • Weight Distribution and Alignment
  • Tension and Relaxation
  • Mechanics of Swing
  • Mechanics of Clean
  • Mechanics of Overhead Lifts
  • Mechanics of Squat

Introduction Review:
Steve’s explanations are simple to understand and contain all that is needed to hit the ground running.

I would also have included a chapter on how to pick a proper weight of a kettlebell.

Volume 2: Swings

  • Prep Lifts – Steve talks about box squats, and limited range of motion swings
  • 2 Arm Swing – mentions some mistakes made while performing a swing
  • 1 Arm Swing
  • Hand-Hand Swing
  • Double Swing
  • Alternating Swing
  • Side Step Swing
  • Walking Swing Forward/Backward
  • Walking Swing Lateral
  • Crescent/Pirouette Swing
  • Double Crescent Swing
  • Multi-Direction Walking Swing – he combines all previous type of swings into one long set of swings.
  • Lazy Swing
  • Girevoy Sport (GS) Swing – Steve talks, Valery Fedorenko demonstrates how the swing is done GS style. It is interesting to see the difference.

    Volume 2: Swings Review:
    I understand he is making an Encyclopedia, and as such his goal is to include as many exercises with kettlebells as possible. My opinion of the kettlebell variations presented? Most of them are useless. Side Step Swings? I don’t think so.

    If I was Steve I would have included a ranking and a prerequisite system to the swing exercises. I can just see some newbies trying Pirouette Swings and checking into a hospital as a result. I would rank exercises from Beginner to Advanced and define prerequisites, such as “do Two Handed Swings before Pirouette Swings”. Common sense? May be, but better be safe than sorry.

    On the positive side, Steve has an ability to present the exercise in a simple way and make it easy to understand. He walks you through each exercise, pointing out details. Once you go past the ugly set, information is of high quality and worth paying attention to.

    Volume 3: Turkish Get Ups(TGU)

    • Lunge Style
    • Lunge Variation
    • Squat Style
    • No Hands
    • Double No Hands
    • Kettlebell Arm Bar

    Volume 3: Turkish Get Ups(TGU) Review:

    I liked Steve’s presentation of Turkish Get Ups. Some of it was a bit lengthy and redundant but overall useful.

    I would like to see some disclaimers and prep exercises for those with knee, shoulder and hip problems.

    Good stuff, but I just can’t get over the ugly set… Is it just me?

    Volume 4: Clean

    • Rack Position
    • 1 Arm Hang Clean
    • 1 Arm Dead Clean
    • Double Rack Walk
    • Double Hang Clean
    • Double Dead Clean
    • Anchored Clean
    • Alternating Clean (2 count)
    • Alternating Clean (1 count)
    • Bottoms Up Clean
    • Double Bottoms Up
    • Crossover Clean
    • Twisting Clean
    • GS Clean (demonstrated by Valery Fedorenko)
    • GS Double Clean(demonstrated by Valery Fedorenko)
    • GS Assistance Lift(Bottoms Up Clean shown by Valery Fedorenko)

    Volume 4: Clean Reaview
    Great job at explaining the clean. A classic exercise, simple explanations, quality!

    Wonderful job Steve. Want to learn how to do clean properly? I would highly recommend watching and reviewing this Volume.

    The only thing that I would add is the prerequisite system. A simple chart would do fine.

    Volume 5: Overhead Press

    • 1 Arm Military Press
    • Side Press
    • Push Press
    • Waiter’s Press
    • 2 Step Forward 1 Step Back
    • Bottoms Up Press
    • 1 Arm 1 Leg
    • Seated Press
    • Double Seated Press
    • Sots Press
    • Double Sots
    • Alternating Sots Presses
    • Double Military Press
    • Alternating Press (2 count)
    • Alternating Press (1 count)
    • Alternating Anchored Press
    • Alternating Twisting Press
    • Double Push Press
    • Overhead Walk
    • Double Overhead Walk
    • GS Press(Valery Fedorendo)
    • GS Double Press(Valery Fedorendo)
    • GS Alternating Press(Valery Fedorendo)
    • GS Push Press(Valery Fedorendo)
    • GS Double Push Press(Valery Fedorendo)
    • GS Assistance Lift( Bottoms Up Press done by Valery Fedorendo

    Volume 5: Overhead Press Review

    What can I say, the guy does a lot of Pressing! :)

    Good variety of exercises, plenty of food to chew on.

    Again, a clear chain of prereqs would work wonders here. Simple shoulder mobility drills would be a nice addition as well.

    Volume 6: Leg Training

    • Introduction to Squatting
    • Deck Squat
    • Plie Squat
    • Elevated Plie
    • Front Squat
    • Double Front Squat
    • Overhead Squat
    • Double Overhead Squat
    • Hack Squat
    • Split Squat/Lunge
    • Racked Lunge
    • Overhead Lunge
    • Lateral Lunge
    • Lateral Overhead Lunge
    • Multi-directional Lunge
    • 1 Leg Squat/Pistol Prep
    • Weighted Pistols
    • Racked Pistols
    • Overhead Pistol
    • Dragon Twisting
    • Racked and Overhead Dragon Twisting
    • Dragon Walking
    • Jumping Lunge
    • Cossack Lunge
    • Duck Squat and Walk
    • Lateral Slipping
    • GS Squat

    Volume 6: Leg Training Review

    Volume 7: One Leg Deadlift(DL)

    • Straight Leg DL
    • Extended Straight Leg DL
    • 1 Leg DL
    • Exteded 1 Leg DL
    • 1 Arm 1 Leg DL
    • Twisting DL

    Volume 7: One Leg Deadlift Review
    Steve focuses on Straight Leg Dead Lifts in this section. Regular Dead Lifts are not covered. Cotter’s argument is that barbells are better for that type of training since dead lifts are used for maximum lifts.

    He right, but he is wrong. As kettlebells become more and more mainstream, baby-boomers, weekend warriors and deconditioned segments of population are getting into the kettlebell game. For many performing a dead lift with a kettlebell is a far superior option than a barbell DL.

    Since he is making an encyclopedia of kettlebell training, presumably is should be complete. I want my dead lift!

    Volume 8: Snatch
    This section covers:

    • Swing Snatch
    • Corkscrew Snatch
    • Dead Position Snatch
    • Double Snatch-Swing style
    • Double Snatch-Clean style
    • Anchored Snatches
    • Alternating Snatch (2 count)
    • Alternating Snatch (1 count)
    • Extended Snatch
    • GS Snatch, done by Valery Fedorenko

    Volume 8: Snatch, Review
    A solid presentation of Snatch How to. GS style snatch is quite useless. I wish Steve would let Valery Fedorenko talk… Note on Valery’s form: It’s is far from perfect. He is a champ and an experienced lifter but beginners should not be trying to mimic his personal style. It’s a disaster waiting to happen.

    Volume 9: Jerk
    Section Covers:

    • Jerk Prep
    • Double Jerk
    • 1 arm GS Jerk
    • GS Double Jerk

    Volume 9: Jerk, Review
    Information is again very nice. GS is a nice addition, Valery is very nice(even though he never speaks) but again useless for a beginner. Instead I would have Coach Fedorenko explain what should be done and in more depth of GS Jerk.

    Volume 10: Clean and Jerk
    Steve shows:

    • 1 Arm Clean and Jerk
    • Double Clean and Jerk
    • Bottoms up Clean and Jerk
    • Double Bottoms up Clean and Jerk
    • 1 Arm Lockout with 2 Kettlebells
    • Use of Belts
    • GS 1 arm Long Cycle(Clean and Jerk performed by Valery Fedorenko)
    • Double GS Long Cycle(Double Clean and Jerk performed by Valery Fedorenko)

    A nice effort by Steve. A comprehensive overview of Clean and Jerk. Simple language, easy to understand.

    Volume 11: Windmills
    Section includes:

    • Windmill Prep
    • Low Mindmill
    • High Windmill
    • High/Low Windmill
    • Elevated Low Windmill
    • Elevated High Windmill
    • Elevated High/Low Windmill

    Volume 11: Windmills, Review
    Solid information. Great presentation.

    Volume 12: Abdominals
    Steve demonstrates:

    • Get Up Sit Up
    • Double Get Up Sit Up
    • Rolling Sit-up
    • Seated Russian Twist
    • Saxon Side Bend
    • Lying Kettlebell Pullover
    • Kettlebell Junda Sit-up
    • Hook Swings
    • Rotations in Rack
    • Over Head Rotations
    • Rotations with High Knees
    • Over Head Rotations With High Knees
    • Towel Swings
    • Low Basin Towel Swings

    Volume 12: Abdominals, Review
    Good presentation. I would recommend going over this volume to Kettlebell Trainer, or Kettlebell User – beginner or advanced.

    Volume 13: Special Lifts
    You will learn:

    • Bent Press
    • 2 Hands Anyhow
    • 1 Arm Floor Press
    • Double Floor Press
    • Alternating Floor Press
    • Bottoms Up Floor Press
    • Waiter’s Floor Press
    • KB Bent Row
    • Double Bent Row
    • Renegate Row
    • Crush Curl and Press
    • Extended Swings
    • KB Towel Curl
    • Open Palm Clean and Press

    Volume 13: Special Lifts, Review
    Advanced stuff. I had fun doing it. Lately I’ve sticking to KB classic exercises and KB juggling. It was a nice refresher and reminder. Thank you Steve.

    Volume 14: Combo Lifts
    Steve demonstrates:

    • Snatch to Overhead Squat
    • Snatch to Overhead Squat to Sots Press
    • Double Snatch to Overhead Squat to Sots Press
    • Clean to Squat to Press
    • Clean to Press to Squat
    • Double Clean to Squat to Press
    • Double Clean to Press to Squat
    • Snatch to Windmill to Press to Overhead Squat

    Volume 14: Combo Lifts, Review
    Nice example but I would love to see more. With so many lifts shown, Steve could have used his creativity a bit more. That said, the lifts shown are nice an useful. More!

    Volume 15: Monster Lifts
    This section might as well be called Steve Cotter and Valery Fedorenko show off.

    Valery does a pinky clean and press with a 32kg and Cotter throws around the beast(48kg kettlebell).

    Entertaining but not very useful.

    Volume 17: Girevoy Sport
    It’s Fedorenko’s time to shine. Valery demonstrated competition style Clean and Jerks(long and short cycle) and Snatches.

    Somewhat entertaining and useful.

    I wish Fedorenko would speak and share his experience with Kettlebell Training. I don’t know if he didn’t speak English, wasn’t comfortable on camera or whatever else, but it is a shame.


    Popularity: 28% [?]





    Comments

    2 Responses to “Review of Steve Cotter’s Encyclopedia of Kettlebell Lifting”

    1. Josh
      August 16th, 2009 @ 7:19 pm

      Thanks for writing this review, Denis. It was very helpful.

    2. adam brushaber
      February 19th, 2010 @ 5:24 am

      Really appreciate all the details in your review!

    Leave a Reply





  • Subscribe to Coach Kanygin’s Blog